This morning, New York State Supreme Court Justice Arthur Cooperman acquitted three detectives of all charges in the 50-shot killing of unarmed groom-to-be Sean Bell in the early hours of his wedding day. The verdict was delivered to a packed courtroom, with a huge crowd gathered outside the courthouse. After the verdict, some crowd members wept and some were enraged, shouting “Murderers!” A phalanx of police ringed the courthouse on Queens Boulevard, prepared for any violence, though there were only some minor scuffles. Justice Cooperman ruled that the prosecution had not proven guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Commenting on the prosecution’s witnesses, he said, “At times, the testimony of those witnesses just didn’t make sense.”
Unlike in federal court, where both the prosecution and the defense must agree for a trial to be conducted without a jury, in state court in New York if criminal defendants wish to proceed with a judge trial, they do not need the consent of the prosecution. Nevertheless, it is rare for defense lawyers to elect this option. Where there is a complex legal issue bearing upon guilt or innocence, it may make sense to waive a jury. In other cases, a defense lawyer may hope that a judge will reduce a charge to a lesser offense by rendering a verdict that is not an outright acquittal but allows for a shorter prison sentence. This is sometimes a viable strategy in murder cases where the hope is for a manslaughter verdict.
The one consistent exception to the general rule against waiving a jury is cases in which criminal defendants are police officers. Almost without fail, in state court trials in New York City involving alleged serious police misconduct, the defense elects to waive a jury and proceed before a judge. Perhaps defense lawyers believe that judges are more informed regarding issues that confront police officers, and thus can be fairer than a jury. Maybe the defense strategy is that in such emotional cases, judges are cooler, calmer, and more collected in their deliberations. Clearly, the defense lawyers made the right call in this case. However, in trials where the police are accused of hurting or killing members of a minority community an unmistakable impression is that those very communities cannot be trusted to be fair and impartial and to serve as judges of the facts. Jury waiver will continue to be the chosen and appropriate strategy and distrust one of the unavoidable public reactions in these sorts of cases as long as “I, the Jury” continues to be the law in this state. CR
Friday, April 25, 2008
I, the jury.
Thursday, April 24, 2008
I’ve got a secret.
The SEC has refused a congressional request to disclose why it dropped its investigation into Bear Stearns’s valuation of bundles of subprime mortgage securities called collateralized debt obligations, according to a story in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal. In an April 2 letter to SEC Inspector General David Kotz, Iowa Republican Senator Charles Grassley requested “a thorough investigation into the facts and circumstances surrounding the agency’s decision not to pursue enforcement action” against the defunct Wall Street firm. SEC Chairman Christopher Cox responded on April 16 that “the Commission does not disclose the existence or nonexistence of an investigation or information generated in any investigation unless made a matter of public record in proceedings brought before the Commission or the courts.” The war over access to this information is expected to continue.
Most of the time I fight with the SEC. But here I agree with Chairman Cox’s position. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of New York is investigating the very same issues that the Senate Finance Committee is seeking to have disclosed by the SEC. It’s no secret that the SEC and federal prosecutors work very closely together on many investigations. Rule 6 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure prohibits unauthorized “leaking” of secret grand jury proceedings. If there is any overlap of confidential facts developed by both the SEC and the U.S. Attorney about the Bear Stearns investigation, there could virtually be a Rule 6 violation if the information is released to the Senate. Individuals and companies under investigation are entitled to protection until and unless allegations are made public by way of a formal accusation. CR
Wednesday, March 26, 2008
Keep the cat in the bag!
On Monday, Albany County District Attorney P. David Soares asked newly minted New York governor David Paterson to allow evidence regarding the Elliot Spitzer / Joseph Bruno “Troopergate” investigation to be released to the public. Yesterday the governor sent New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo a letter requesting a “formal advisory opinion” on waivers of executive privilege and the secrecy rules surrounding grand jury presentations.
While the press has focused on the issue of executive waiver, the real story seems to me to be the DA’s request for a “waiver of Grand Jury secrecy” under a specific section of the New York Criminal Procedure Law that deals with motions to quash subpoenas. As I told New York Times reporter Danny Hakim when he called me yesterday for comment, a grand jury is ostensibly a protection for us all. It is a buffer between the unfettered power of the state and an individual citizen’s rights. A prosecutor convenes a grand jury to go after bad guys. If there are no charges, then the grand jury process should not be made public. That’s what the rules say. By the way, it’s nice to have a law professor of the stature of Stephen Gillers say I got it right! CR